Spotify recently announced that it would show public play counts on all podcasts to help attract new fans.”But this update didn’t sit well with many podcasters, who quickly criticized the move. Their main concern? That public play counts would boost already-famous shows and hurt small creators by making them look less popular.

Spotify Updates Its Strategy

After strong backlash, Spotify decided to change course. Now, the play counts will only be visible on podcasts that reach at least 50,000 plays. Also, instead of exact numbers, it will only show rounded milestones like 100,000 or 1 million plays.

Spotify said in a blog post:

“We plan to roll this newly evolved version of play counts over the coming week. This update reflects our evolving efforts to provide the best insights for creators and a clear experience for their fans.”

Why Podcast Creators Were Unhappy

For a long time, podcast platforms didn’t show public popularity stats. For example, Apple Podcasts only have ratings and charts, not play numbers. Many creators actually liked this system because it gave smaller podcasts a chance to grow, without being compared to big shows. In contrast, platforms like YouTube always show how many views a video has making it harder for new content to stand out. That’s why many podcasters felt Spotify’s new rule would unfairly benefit big names.

Confusion Over What Counts as a “Play”

Another issue creators raised was the lack of clarity about what actually counts as a “play” or a stream. The Interactive Advertising Bureau (IAB) works with platforms to define these terms, but Spotify and YouTube don’t always follow the same standard. Spotify explained that play counts are based on how many times people actively tried to listen. But for something to count as a stream or download, it needs at least 60 seconds of listening time.

What This Means for Podcasting

Spotify tried to increase transparency with this update, but it sparked controversy instead. While their revised plan might be more balanced, the bigger debate continues about how to grow the podcast industry without pushing smaller creators out of the spotlight.